National Council of Teachers of English Logo

On Writing

Through its National Gallery of Writing NCTE hopes to create a national portrait of America writing and to use the knowledge of who writes today, why, and what matters most to them to better understand how to use The NCTE Beliefs about the Teaching of Writing to advance writers everywhere but questions remain.

Are we in the midst of a writing revolution? Are more people composing than ever before—writing with more sophisticated tools for more nuanced purposes? Or are we mired in a crisis marked by a decline in both the style and substance of writing?

  • In the third of his three-part series of New York Times Op-Eds, “What Should Colleges Teach?” (September 7, 2007), Stanley Fish says we have a writing crisis and argues that composition instruction in college needs to focus on forms that students must master in order to be articulate writers.
  • Kathleen Blake Yancey, in her report Writing in the 21st Century suggests, “We …face three challenges that are also opportunities: developing new models of writing; designing a new curriculum supporting those models; and creating models for teaching that curriculum."

What do you think?
Do students write as well as they used to? 
How do we best teach students to write?

Make your comments on this hot topic below.

 

Document and Site Resources

Comments

Most Recent Comments (24 Total Posts)

Posted By: Anonymous User on 3/22/2011 10:47:08 AM

As an English teacher in a state where high-stakes testing involves "on-demand" writing, I am being told by my superiors that the only kinds of writinting that matter are the kinds found on the test. I have little time in my teaching year to engage students in writing experiences that don't conform what my state's test asks for. As much as I'd love to do creative pieces, the gravity high-stakes testing will pull our curriculums ever away from authentic, creative writing endeavors. As a newcomer here, I don't know how the NCTE views these tests, but to me - and I'm sure many others on the front lines - they are slowly stifling to death what makes English fun and relevent to students.

Posted By: Anonymous User on 10/8/2009 8:37:23 AM

Students need to be able to write in a variety of genres for different audiences and purposes. Many schools have curriculums that focus on narrative, prompt, and essay writing. While these genres and styles of writing have their place, they give students little exposure to other writing possibilitis. When confined within these types of writing students do not have the chance to develop a voice and style of their own--to learn the power of the written word. The quantity of writing that students do is very important and needs to occur in a variety of subject areas, not just language arts classes. Also, it is time to start looking at technology and opportunities for digital writing that are engaging for students and will help them to learn 21st century skills.

Posted By: Anonymous User on 10/7/2009 6:32:20 PM

Consider, as well, that many of our students are multi-lingual and think in a different order of composition. Does this factor, perhaps, contribute to the murky waters of poor writing performance? As a nation, do we have a national communication standard? Do we, in fact, know or acknowledge what the principal language is in the United States?

Posted By: Anonymous User on 10/7/2009 6:30:55 PM

I propose that we ask students to produce samples of what they deem to be good writing and ask them to defend their selections. This should serve as springboards for many discussions As instructors, we may also post samples of commendable writing (representing various genres).

Posted By: Anonymous User on 10/7/2009 6:29:56 PM

Are we writing, as journalists, in the pyramid style? As technical writers is the message being produced for brevity, clarity and coherence? As advertisers and marketers are we creating a message to reach the masses utilizing quippy, catchy, if not gimmicky and often not "technically correct" spelling or form? As novelists producing fiction, romance, biography, docu-drama writers are we striving for a clarity and appeal that will encourage the reader to keep on reading? Like pictoral artists are we striving to paint, with words, creative, compelling or coherent messages in sparse but effective and variable sentence and paragraph structure.. And what of dashes; the use of ellipsis; commas; capital letters, italics, quotes? Are these the sugar and spice of blogs, twitters, facebook postings, texting trivia and a host of other morphing message methods, often dictated by cost per character, amount of attention span or importance to a few and insignificance to many?

Page Tools:

Related Search Terms

What Is "College-Level" Writing?
What Works in Writing Instruction
Strategic Writing
Using the Writer's Notebook in Grades 308

Copyright

Copyright © 1998-2012 National Council of Teachers of English. All rights reserved in all media.

1111 W. Kenyon Road, Urbana, Illinois 61801-1096 Phone: 217-328-3870 or 877-369-6283

Looking for information? Browse our FAQs, tour our sitemap and store sitemap, or contact NCTE

Read our Privacy Policy Statement and Links Policy. Use of this site signifies your agreement to the Terms of Use