National Council of Teachers of English Logo
Technology Can Not Replace the Teacher

Technology Can Not Replace the Teacher

When I began teaching six years ago, I longed for the most modern technology available to students. To that end, I wrote a grant to obtain a writing program for my class. The program did not meet my expectations. Then, we moved to the next level of technology, computers and whiteboards. Initially, I set up a website so my class could access information from class. Most recently, I began helping students on weekends and snow days via email.
But technology is not always dependable. The Internet goes down, and only an English teacher can properly grade an essay and conference with a student afterward.  Thus, in the past six years I have learned that technology can not replace the teacher and that students want to learn from humans, not machines. Technology has become a supplement to my lesson plans and not the primary focal point that I thought it would be.

Kim Bochicchio
Dunmore High School
Dunmore, Pennsylvania
6 years as a teacher
(10 years as Director of Community Education- North Pocono School District, Moscow, Pennsylvania)

Related Resources..

Computers in the Writing Classroom

 Author(s): Dave Moeller

 

 Divided into two parts, this book provides teachers with guidance for incorporating computers into the writing classroom and for making computers the essential tool for writing and writing instruction.

 

 

Reshaping High School English

Author(s): Bruce Pirie

 

Reshaping High School English describes an English program that blends philosophical depth with classroom practicality, offering refreshing insights on textuality, media studies, drama, and the five-paragraph essay.

 

 

 

Document and Site Resources

Comments

Most Recent Comments (5 Total Posts)

Posted By: Anonymous User on 12/6/2011 9:49:06 AM

mindblowing

Posted By: Anonymous User on 8/22/2011 11:01:16 AM

yo myo yo

Posted By: Anonymous User on 6/13/2011 9:41:11 PM

I completely agree! Technology can never replace a teacher. I am a year 6 student from primary school in NSW. I am doing a debate on the topic "Technology should replace teachers" i am negative. Computers can strain your eyes. I would much rather use books and stationary then computers. What if the students don't understand what to do and there are no teachers there to explain what to do? Where would the students do their work? What if their parents are at work and they can't stay at home to do their work? How would 4-6 year olds complete their work if they can't read or write or spell or tell the time or add? I just hope that technology hasn't taken over by the time my unborn brother starts school.

Posted By: Anonymous User on 6/13/2011 9:35:01 PM

I completely agree! Technology can never replace a teacher. I am a student from year 6 primary school NSW. I am doing a debate oon the topic "Technology should replace teachers" and I'm negative. I know from my experience that I would much rather learnn from an actual person then from a computer. Computers can strain your eyes. I'd much rather use books & stationary then the computer. What if we don't understand something and there are no teachers to explain it to us? Where would we do the work? What if 4-6 year olds were using the computer? They wouldn't know how to read or spell or anything like that. I just ho-pe that technology hasn't taken over before my unborn brother gets to school.

Posted By: Anonymous User on 2/15/2009 2:20:50 PM

Interesting- nothing can replace the human touch that is involved in teaching. A machine can not encourage, reflect, and or cheer on the learner.

Page Tools:

Related Search Terms

Copyright

Copyright © 1998-2012 National Council of Teachers of English. All rights reserved in all media.

1111 W. Kenyon Road, Urbana, Illinois 61801-1096 Phone: 217-328-3870 or 877-369-6283

Looking for information? Browse our FAQs, tour our sitemap and store sitemap, or contact NCTE

Read our Privacy Policy Statement and Links Policy. Use of this site signifies your agreement to the Terms of Use